Charlie Hebdo’s Editor-in-Chief Gerard Biard, and its film critic Jean-Baptiste Thoret, in conversation with Suzanne Nossel, Executive Director of PEN American Center, and Ed Berenson, NYU’s Director of the Institute of French Studies. The discussion touched upon challenges to free expression in France and Europe, the role of satire in open societies, the controversies that have surrounded Charlie Hebdo, and the tensions between respect for religious differences and protections for freedom of expression.